“Mother Nursing her Child by the Fireplace,” Albert Neuhuys. Public domain.

Restoring Trust in Medicine

Below is an edited version of the remarks that Katie Vidmar originally delivered in Rochester on September 18th as part of a breakout session on “Women’s Health” at the 2026 Women’s Convention. We will be publishing remarks from Dr. Angela Kristan and Helen Nguyen later this week. A full, unedited video of the breakout session can be viewed here.

The poet Horace once said, “You may drive nature out with a pitchfork, but she keeps on coming back.” This ancient epigraph captures something important about the current paradigm of women’s health. We are continually surprised—and perhaps even angered—when the nature of our female bodies keeps “coming back,” despite our very best attempts to suppress it. Whether we consciously realize it or not, many of us feel that dissonance within our own bodies. We feel it, too, in the healthcare we receive as women, most especially when it comes to our reproductive health.

It is a dissonance with serious consequences. Trust in healthcare is eroding, especially among women. Nationally, the share of American adults reporting a “great deal” or “quite a lot” of trust in physicians and hospitals fell from 71.5 percent in April 2020 to 40.1 percent in January 2024. That’s a 31-point drop in under four years, tracked across 24 survey waves and more than 440,000 respondents in all 50 states. The researchers found the decline held “regardless of gender.” But being female is also associated with lower trust in 2023–24, alongside younger or middle age, lower income, lower education, being Black, and rural residence.

The lack of trust can be explained, in part, by data from other surveys, which show that women are routinely disbelieved and dismissed by their own doctors. For example, a large, nationally representative, peer-reviewed federal-adjacent survey from KFF (formerly the Kaiser Family Foundation), a nonpartisan health policy research organization, found that:

  • 34 percent of women reported at least one negative healthcare experience in the past two years.
  • 18 percent of women said a healthcare provider “didn’t believe [they] were telling the truth.”
  • 20 percent of women said a provider “ignored a direct request they made or question they asked.”
  • 19 percent of women said a provider “assumed something about them without asking.”
  • 13 percent of women said a provider “suggested they were personally to blame for a health problem they were experiencing.”
  • 10 percent of women said a provider “refused to prescribe them pain medication they thought they needed.”

The gaps widen even more sharply for specific groups. Over half of women who identify as LGBT+ and nearly half of women with disabilities reported a negative healthcare experience. Among women who felt treated unfairly or disrespectfully by a healthcare professional, rates were 26 percent for black women, 25 percent for Hispanic women, and 21 percent for white women, with lower-income women reporting negative experiences at notably higher rates than higher-income women.

Those numbers are jarring, but they become even worse when applied to a female-specific condition. Take, for example, a May 2025 study, where researchers surveyed 447 patients with vulvovaginal pain disorders (conditions notorious for long diagnostic delays) about their experiences with clinicians.

39.4 percent of patients said a clinician had made them feel “crazy.” This was the single most distressing behavior patients reported, and the one that researchers said made women feel “gaslit.” Furthermore:

  • 41.6 percent were told by a clinician to simply “relax more.”
  • 20.5 percent said a clinician did not believe their concerns at all.
  • 26.6 percent rated a past provider’s behavior as “belittling.”
  • 52.8 percent said they had considered abandoning care altogether because their concerns went unaddressed.

As many longtime Fairer Disputations readers are likely aware, women’s pain is often ignored or dismissed by healthcare professionals. For example, in a peer-reviewed analysis of more than 21,000 emergency-department records across the U.S. and Israel, women were consistently less likely than men to be prescribed pain medication for comparable complaints, regardless of the treating physician’s own gender; nurses were 10 percent less likely to record a pain score at all for female patients; and women stayed in the ER an average of 30 minutes longer than men before being seen.

The issue of pain is particularly stark when we consider endometriosis, an excruciating condition affecting an estimated 10 percent (190 million) of women of reproductive age worldwide. The World Health Organization reports that the average time to diagnosis for endometriosis is between 4 and 12 years. This delay is widely attributed in the clinical literature to patients’ pain being repeatedly minimized or dismissed before a diagnosis is pursued.

Body Literacy and Cycle-Informed Care

In her recent book, The Period Brain, Dr. Sarah Hill writes:

Female sex hormones are an integral part of female normal. And female normal has two halves. And when we’re only given half of the story of ourselves, everything that goes on in the last two weeks of our cycle can feel like a pathology. The one-size-fits-all approach to understanding humans doesn’t work for women. It makes us feel like something about us is broken. And most of us have no choice but to believe this, that this narrative is true, because we haven’t ever been told what it looks like when things are going right.

While Dr. Hill doesn’t use the words “body literacy” or “cycle-informed reproductive healthcare” here, her explanation of female hormones, cycles, and the way they are integrated within the whole of the female person offers a good framework for understanding those terms.

In the simplest terms: If literacy is the ability to read, to take the signs and symbols of language and to interpret their meaning, body literacy is the ability to understand the signs and symptoms that our body is communicating to us every day, and to understand what they mean.

In reading, letters build into words, words build into sentences, and sentences build into paragraphs, which then become a full story. In a similar way, when we start to pay attention to our body day by day, week by week, and month by month, the story it’s telling us begins to unfold. With practice, we find that we can actually understand it. What’s more, this understanding then becomes a grounding horizon by which we, as women, can steward our health and fertility.

Cycle-informed care, then, is simply an approach to healthcare that understands the female cycle, that’s fluent in the language of the body, and that sees the cycle as a vital sign of health, in which we prioritize keeping the cycle intact. Not disrupting, not circumventing, but allowing that cycle to unfold naturally, month after month, and year after year.

There Is No Informed Consent Without Body Literacy

I came to believe that informed consent is impossible without body literacy through my experience as executive director of a nonprofit women’s clinic in North Dakota. The clinic popped up when oil was booming in the Bakken Formation, and a formerly sleepy agricultural community suddenly found itself number one in the nation for human trafficking.

An intrepid group of individuals got the clinic up and off the ground, and it had been successfully operating for a year when I interviewed to be their executive director. The board chair noted that I had a fertility awareness educator credential on my resume, and said something that would shape the way I would come to view women’s health to this day:

Anywhere there’s health illiteracy, health disparities follow. And we think we can get upstream of a lot of harmful experiences that women have if we can reach them ahead of time, and help them understand how their bodies work in the first place, and allow this knowledge to give them greater freedom in the choices that they’re making in their healthcare, in their relationships, and in their life at large.

Then came the ask: could I figure out how to bring body literacy and fertility awareness to their patients, many of whom had low literacy, didn’t speak English as a first language, and were underinsured or uninsured? The clinic felt very strongly—as did I—that this kind of body literacy education should be for everyone, not just for privileged white women who are already partnered. So I agreed to try.

It ended up being more difficult—and more rewarding—than I could have imagined.

A Trust-Restoring Practice

The women walking through our doors often lacked even a very basic understanding of their bodies. And yet, we found that when we were able to integrate body literacy and introduce them to a kind of care that worked with their body’s natural design, it truly did move the needle for them. It impacted not only specific healthcare outcomes but their larger life goals as well. This is because cycle-informed care helps restore women’s trust in their own body’s ability to heal, and in medicine as well.

It also bears repeating, given the suspicion this concept has received from certain corners, that reading a cycle chart isn’t a fringe behavior. It is not a form of alternative medicine. The menstrual cycle is a fifth vital sign, and it has been clearly defined as such by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) for the last ten years. Monitoring this sign can improve healthcare. One 2023 study, for example, examined the relationship between cycle abnormalities and heart conditions. It uncovered significant and specific correlations between cycle symptoms and various cardiovascular problems. Studies like this one help to build the evidence base for physicians, demonstrating that cycle data provides whole-body health signals that matter. Cycle-informed care, then, is simply using the cycle chart the way that ACOG has told us we should for the last decade.

Shifting the Power Differential in Healthcare

Body literacy and cycle tracking also have the potential to meaningfully shift the power differential inherent in medicine. Havi Carel and Ian James Kidd, known for their influential 2014 paper on the concept of epistemic injustice in healthcare, say that there are two primary mechanisms by which women become structurally disempowered in their healthcare.

The first is testimonial injustice: women are seen as too emotional, too anxious, and so they’re simply not believed. And then there’s hermeneutical injustice, in which women lack a shared vocabulary to use terms in the clinical encounter that their physician recognizes as evidence. Carel and Kidd therefore recommend a conceptual toolkit to equip women with the language that they need to be able to speak at the doctor’s level. A cycle chart is precisely the toolkit that Carel and Kidd are calling for. I’ve seen it in action many times, both in person and in the literature. For example, a 2025 Finnish study showed that when women with painful periods presented knowledgeable physicians with their cycle charts (which also included dates, times, symptoms, and other metrics), their time to treatment was reduced radically compared to those who were not charting their cycles.

To further illustrate the point: the educational organization Facts About Fertility conducted a study, published in 2024, in which they surveyed 571 medical and nursing students across 103 U.S. schools, all of whom took a short online elective in fertility awareness-based methods. The online elective was shown to produce a statistically significant improvement in the future physicians’ and nurses’ knowledge and confidence in discussing cycles with patients. Perhaps most strikingly, participation in the elective flipped clinical intent: before training, most of the future doctors said they were not likely to incorporate cycle charts into their care. That number fell significantly after the elective.

What these studies make abundantly clear is that both sides of the conversation must be fluent in the language of the body: Patients need the vocabulary to express it, and clinicians need the fluency to receive it.

Elevate + The Body Literacy Project

A growing coalition of people wants to receive this kind of healthcare, and a growing cohort of healthcare professionals wants to offer it to them. Of course, how we achieve this fluency, especially given the significant challenges, is the question of the moment.

The women walking through the doors of the clinic I ran in North Dakota were smart and capable. Given the socioeconomic realities of their lives, some of them were also homeless. Some had multiple partners, several small children already, difficult employment situations, and impossibly hard relationships.

What I call the “legacy” fertility awareness method model was, simply put, not a fit. The lengthy and expensive training required to become a fertility awareness educator likewise made the credential out of reach for most of my staff members. And, frankly, most of our patients were not in a place in their lives where it made sense for them to sit through a three-and-a-half-hour-long session over the course of several weeks, let alone abstain from sex for an entire cycle, as the legacy model recommends.

Taking a page out of Maria Montessori’s philosophy of education—in which concepts are not watered down, but distilled to what’s simple, essential, and easily shareable—we created materials in this spirit. The result was a program called Elevate, which currently serves 37 clinical sites nationwide.

Rather than asking women to sit through an hour-and-a-half-long intro session, Elevate offers a five-minute body literacy flip chart which covers, at a high level, all of the same content, but in a way that can actually be delivered in a 20-minute clinical encounter. We likewise created social media content, textable patient information sheets, printable rack cards, short- and long-form educational videos, and nursing protocols for four simplified, evidence-based fertility awareness methods that can be taught in one appointment.

And finally, we taught both clinicians and patients to learn the parameters of a healthy cycle and to more quickly flag abnormalities, reducing the time to treatment for reproductive health issues like PMOS/PCOS and endometriosis.

Most recently, we also created a school-based curriculum in body literacy, intended to be auxiliary content added on to existing health curricula. It includes four lessons for girls and a short curriculum for boys, given that boys also need and deserve to know how their male bodies work.

Withholding Information Is a Popular Form of Coercion

Despite our successes, we have run into opposition along the way from people and organizations on both sides of the political spectrum who are wary of this information—and of providing it to people. Reckoning with a society that systematically attempts to keep women in the dark about how their bodies work has made it clear to me that withholding information is a form of coercion. It’s particularly popular to withhold information from women. As Lisa Hendrickson-Jack observes in her book The Fifth Vital Sign, if you keep a population illiterate, they’re much easier to use, abuse, and control.

It’s easier to convince a woman to accept healthcare that is suppressive and circumventive if she doesn’t know that she’s experiencing it in the first place. If she’s not literate about her body, she has no way to know.

Although cycle charting is common among people of faith, some Christians believe that unmarried women shouldn’t have access to this knowledge. As someone once chided me, “To teach a girl that she can’t get pregnant in the absence of cervical fluid is pretty much the same thing as giving her hormonal birth control. In either case, you are giving her permission to sin against the Sixth Commandment.”

I couldn’t disagree more.

The message is the same from both the secular medical establishment and Christians like these: You can’t handle the truth of your body. We know what’s best for you, and we’re going to decide for you. But, in the words of Frederick Douglass, “Once you learn to read, you will be forever free.”

Author Jennifer Block argued in her book, Everything Below the Waist, that it is time for women to demand “a kind of healthcare that’s more respectful of female physiology,” paired with “a more health-conscious feminism, one that reframes empowerment to include not only control of our bodies, but also our right to support, protect, and enjoy them.” Without honest, transparent information about their bodies, women aren’t making real choices about their healthcare. They are simply complying.

Teaching body literacy works to restore trust: both between physicians and patients, and, for women, within their very bodies. Body literacy frees women from the dissonant notion that the functions of their female bodies must be controlled and suppressed for their own good, and it empowers them to demand a medical system that will help them truly flourish as women.


Subscribe